Edwards' hit came off new Yankees reliever Camilo Doval (4-3), and Edwards beat the attempted tag at home on Ramirez's fielder's choice grounder. After Edwards' single off Doval, Jose Caballero, also a newcomer, committed an error in right field, allowing the Marlins to tie the score. Ramirez singled twice, including a leadoff base hit and a go-ahead single that put the Marlins up 10-9. Volpe, who had four hits, gave the Yankees a two-run cushion with a run-scoring double. Rodon held the Marlins without a hit before Eric Wagaman's leadoff single in the fifth.